What Is The Best Tomato For Caprese Salad

Must Try

How Long Does Tomato And Mozzarella Salad Last

Best CAPRESE SALAD | Recipe for Caprese Salad

A pre-prepped salad should last about 2-3 days but better eat this while it is made fresh otherwise the salt in mozzarella will draw out all the water from the tomatoes and will make the whole dish soggy after a few days. If you come to that point, just drain the whole thing and add a new dressing!

Dont know what to cook next? Heres some inspiration:

Rule #: Don’t F#& k With It

This is by far the most important rule.

With most recipes, once you’ve gathered the ingredients, you’re ready to begin cooking. With a Caprese salad, you’re done. The less cooking you do, the better. In fact, the less thought you put into it, the better. Cut your tomatoes up into random bite-size pieces, arrange them on a plate, sprinkle them with salt. Tear up your mozzarella and nestle it into the tomato. Take a brief second to admire how the milky juices of the mozzarella and the watery juices of the tomato mingle on the plate.

Tear up your basil leaves by hand , and scatter them over the top. Season everything with a little more salt and pepper, drizzle with tons of olive oil , and put it on the table with some forks.

Put away that vinegar. I’m serious about this one. I see you creeping.Step away from the balsamic vinegar! If your tomatoes and mozzarella are good enough, the only thing balsamic vinegar will do is cover up their flavor. If your tomatoes and mozzarella are not great, you shouldn’t be making this salad. Not to mention the fact that your balsamic vinegar is most likely just wine vinegar with caramel color added to it. You thought olive oil labeling was shady? Look into the sordid world of balsamic vinegar. Or don’t, if you don’t want to become a cretinous, grumpy food snob like me.

Getting the former right will certainly help with the latter.

What Is Caprese Salad

Caprese salad literally means salad from the island of Capri – a beautiful, serene island in Southern Italy. Traditional Caprese salads use fresh tomatoes, beautiful and creamy mozzarella , basil, extra virgin olive oil, salt and pepper. Occasionally, folks will drizzle balsamic vinegar or pesto. However, I recommend saving that for when you might not be able to get the freshest of summer ingredients).

Don’t Miss: How To Make Veg Salad

Balsamic Glaze For Caprese Salad

Some Caprese salad purists like to enjoy the salad with just tomatoes, mozzarella, basil and olive oil. But heres the thingcaprese is probably a relatively new dish, likely dating back to the 1920s, and so theres no need to be totally married to any one particular way of doing things. We are not on hallowed ground here! So, we happen to love the extra zip and zing that a little drizzle of homemade balsamic reduction adds to a Caprese. It seeps into the fresh mozzarella and swims around with the tomato juices that swirl on the plate and when the last bite of Caprese salad is gone? Grab some bread and start sopping up all of those heady, balsamic-kissed juices. Plus, its really easy to make a balsamic glazesimply simmer some balsamic vinegar for about ten minutes and youve got yourself a slightly syrupy balsamic glaze.

What Are Heirloom Tomatoes

How to Make The Best Caprese Salad

Heirloom tomatoes are what tomatoes used to be before all of the variety and flavor were bred out of them so they could be more easily transported in trucks to supermarkets.

You can find them at farmers’ markets, Whole Foods and many supermarkets these days, or you can grow your own. They come in many shades of red, yellow, orange, and green, and are somewhat oddly shaped compared to everyday beefsteak tomatoes.

Heirloom tomatoes bruise more easily than conventional tomatoes, so you have to handle them with a little more care. They cost more, too, but they’re worth it! They’re juicy and have wonderful flavor.

You May Like: Who Made The Potatoe Salad Free Movie

Choosing The Best Ingredients

This salad is super simple, which means each ingredient has a chance to shine. We recommend using the highest-quality tomatoes and cheese you can find.

  • Tomatoes: Heirloom tomatoes, for example, are a gorgeous, delicious addition to this salad. Theyre available in many beautiful colors, and their complex flavors will really elevate the dish more than Romas or on-the-vine tomatoes. But dont buy blindly, learn about the varieties here.
  • Mozzarella: As for cheese, fresh is best. Look for mozzarella di bufala or buffalo mozzarella on the label and choose a larger piece thatll help you slice large pieces for layering.
  • Basil: Look for fresh basil thats green throughout and has not begun to wilt. If you have the option, choose Genovese basil, an Italian variety thats sweetness will help the dish shine.

Secret #: The Best Mozzarella Matters

Of course, the cheese for a Caprese salad has to be mozzarella. It’s the only cheese able to add that pearly-white touch that a true Caprese has.

But not all mozzarellas are made equal. It’s important to choose the one that adds greatest taste and texture to your salad. So, what to look for?

The vacuum-packed mozzarella floating in liquid you’ll often find in supermarkets is very bland and a bit milky. Try to buy the best mozzarella you can find – you’ll be amazed at the difference it will make.

How to know whether you’re getting a quality product? Simple. Check the ingredients on the packet.

Mozzarella takes time to produce. The more expensive cheeses contain only milk, salt, rennet and enzymes. If you see ingredients such as “curd” or “citric acid” you’ll know the process was speeded up.

The result of that is a poorer quality mozzarella – one that’s also much more salty, because salt is added to try to disguise the bland taste.

When you get it home, push the surface slightly – you should see a few drops of whey – a whitish liquid – appear on the surface.

Smoked mozzarella – a thing of beauty and a taste to die for.

Experiment with different types and brands. Try “mozzarella affumicata” – smoked mozzarella – you’ll find it in good delis. Smoked over wood chips, it’s drier than other types and the surface becomes a light brown colour. It has a very strong taste though, so use it sparingly.

Also Check: How To Make Salad In A Jar

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

  • 15 minute, six ingredient recipe. Seriously, get the fresh ingredients, chop them up and you’re in for a treat!
  • Perfect for all your summertime needs and can make a great addition to any dinner party appetizer platter.
  • Authentic recipe. This is a simple recipe but the tips and tricks I use are all from my time living in Rome!

Rule #: Get Excellent Fresh Mozzarella

A simple recipe for Caprese Salad with Summer Peaches & Tomatoes the perfect tomato slicing knife.

Fresh mozzarella comes in a few forms, in decreasing order of goodness. And, to be clear, we’re talking fresh, as in the pale white stuff that comes in balls, either in brine or in vacuum-sealed bags. We are not talking about low-moisture or aged mozzarella, which has a yellowish hue and comes in rectangular bricks designed for grating. The number of times in the past that I’ve had Caprese salads made with block mozzarella is directly related to the number of times I’ve wanted to manually tear out my toenails in frustration. You can certainly make your own, but if you’re looking to buy, here’s what to look for.

Word of advice: If you have fresh mozzarella from the dairy, do not refrigerate it, as this will cause it to tighten and lose its juicy texture. If you find yourself with refrigerated mozzarella, the best way to restore it to its former glory is by submerging it in warm, salty milk for a spell.

Read Also: Best Salad For Kidney Disease

Tips To Make A Caprese Salad

  • Slice the tomatoes and mozzarella into evenly sized pieces so that you get even bites of everything. It really helps for best presentation too
  • Use room temperature tomatoes. Warmer tomatoes are so much more flavorful than those straight out of the fridge. Take them out at least an hour before you plan to make this recipe.
  • Use small basil leaves. They have a more intense flavor than the larger ones.
  • Add balsamic vinegar or balsamic glaze. While its not traditional to add balsamic vinegar based on the original Italian recipe, its very common to include it in the U.S. I prefer balsamic glaze or reduced balsamic vinegar for its sweeter taste.
  • Top Tips And Ingredient Notes

    • Fresh basil leaves. Use whole or half leaves – a few brown spots are okay – but if it has large brown, black, or slimy spots, you should probably toss those!
    • Mozzarella or burrata cheese, or mozzarella packed in water. You can also use burrata
    • Heirloom tomatoes are the best tomatoes for Caprese salad. But you can also use any fresh garden tomato, cherry or vine tomatoes. I’ve used a mix of heirloom beefsteak tomatoes and cherry tomatoes. I try to avoid other varieties with high water content!
    • Use a combination of salt and flaky sea salt . This adds texture as well as flavor to the dish!
    • Use extra virgin olive oil. Good quality olive oil is not expensive, but try to get the best possible EVOO you can.

    Don’t Miss: Chicken Salad Chick E Gift Card

    Simple Stacked Or Layered Caprese Salad

    Caprese Salad in its simplest form is just a slice of Mozzarella Cheese layered with a slice of tomato and a basil leaf and dressed with olive oil, salt and pepper. I personally like to finely slice the basil as opposed to using a whole leaf I find it easier to eat. I also love the American addition of balsamic glaze, which you can purchase ready made in the grocery store near the balsamic vinegar. It adds a fantastic sweetness and tang.

    What Does Caprese Salad Go With

    Peach Tomato Caprese Salad

    I can list lots of dishes that go well with Caprese salad but I personally love it on its own with a nice glass of Sancerre on a super nice sunny afternoon just before my siesta.

    But, if youre looking for food pairings then:

    • I could easily devour a tomato mozzarella salad on the side of a beautifully grilled chicken
    • As a filling in a baguette with pesto sauce
    • On top of a bed of crispy romaine salad with a lovely balsamic vinegar dressing
    • On top of freshly cooked pasta with pesto sauce
    • Besides a lovely roasted beef, and so on

    It basically goes with whatever.

    Don’t Miss: Jersey Mike’s Chicken Salad

    Roasted Tomato Caprese Salad

    I live in the South, and it gets hot in the summer. After the heat of the day, Im just not in the mood for a heavy dinner. I also dont want to turn on my oven and heat up the house even more than it already is.

    This roasted tomato salad is easy to make on the stove. Its ready in about 10 minutes, so its perfect for busy weeknights. Eat it as a vegetarian dinner, or serve it as a light side dish with grilled meat or pasta.

    A traditional Caprese salad is served at room temperature, but this roasted tomato salad is served warm. Roasting the tomatoes gives them more depth to their flavor. It makes them rich and almost makes this Caprese salad recipe taste like lasagna.

    The flavors of the tomatoes, basil and cheese come together to create a simple but delicious roasted tomato Caprese salad. Since this is a simple dish, I recommend using the highest quality ingredients that you can find. I find that finding bocconcini cheese is best, but a high quality mozzarella cheese will also make a good substitution for this easy dinner recipe.

    This Caprese salad recipe is easy to modify. You can change the dressing that you use and the cheese, so you can make it to complement your main dish or just change the flavor if you serve it often.

    It May Look Simple But There Are Secrets To Making A Caprese Salad That’s As Delicious As Those You’ll Be Served In Italy

    This most well-known of all Italian salad recipes may be served almost everywhere, but it’s not as straightforward as you might think to make a good one.

    If you’ve ever eaten one outside of Italy – and even some within the country – you’ll know how dreadful they can taste. Bland, watery, and in need of lots of salt and herbs to cheer them up.

    But it doesn’t have to be that way.

    Read on to discover the secrets that will make your Caprese salad the talk of the town – whether that town is in Italy or on the other side of the world.

    You May Like: Healthy Low Calorie Salad Dressing

    More About Best Tomatoes For Caprese Recipes






    FromTotal TimeCategoryCalories

    • We have to slice the tomatoes, so we started with the big ones that we washed and cut them in half first, then I cut them in half again and sliced it. continued with the yellow tomatoes, which is a little smaller I only cut them in two and then I sliced it. Slice the two pieces of mozzarella, into not too large slices, ideally, it should be the size of tomato slices.
    • Place the red and yellow sliced tomatoes on a larger plate. Season them with sea salt, freshly ground pepper and dried oregano. Place the mozzarella among the tomato slices and finish with the cherry tomatoes cut in half. Break some fresh basil leaves and spread it over the tomatoes. Sprinkle everything with extra virgin olive oil and a little balsamic vinegar.


    • Add halved cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese balls and fresh chopped basil to a bowl and mix well.

    FromTotal TimeCategoryCalories

    • Drizzle over the olive oil and Balsamic and season with salt and pepper then top the 4 bottom halves with the mozzarella and basil leaves. Add the tops of the tomatoes.


    Layered Fresh Caprese Salad

    Tomato & Mozzarella Salad with Burrata Cheese How to Make the World’s Sexiest Caprese Salad

    Summer time means a bounty of tomatoes, whether from your own garden, or the farmers market, or your grocery store. Nothing highlights the flavor of a good tomato like a classic caprese salad. Its not rocket science, and you dont even need a recipe, but Ive got some tips today on a couple different ways to prepare the very beset caprese salad! This is a classic Italian dish involving tomatoes, basil and fresh mozzarella, and dressed simply with olive oil, salt and pepper. Its named after the island of Capri, where it is said to have originated and it pairs nicely with so many things! Keep reading to see how I turn this classic combo into a Layered Fresh Caprese Salad, which is perfect for serving for a crowd.

    Also Check: Where To Buy Marzetti Salad Dressing

    How To Serve Caprese Salad

    I like to serve caprese salad at room temperature. This means after making the salad, I leave it to marinate for 1 hour before serving it. This allows enough time for the ingredients to reach room temperature.

    If you prefer a dry salad that doesnt have the excess marinade, serve the salad immediately after dressing. The less time you allow the tomatoes to sit in salt and vinegar, the less water they will release.

    TIP: Serve crusty bread for sopping up the excess dressing.

    As a flexible side dish, caprese salad can go with many different foods, including sandwiches, burgers, pizza, fish, poultry , and red meat .

    Best Tomatoes For Caprese

    The freshest and ripest tomatoes, bursting with flavor, are the best for caprese salad. My recipe uses heirloom tomatoes, which are multi-colored and packed with flavor.

    You can also use grape tomatoes, cherry tomatoes, beefsteak tomatoes, or plum tomatoes . Any kind of tomato you can find at the store works.

    TIP: The most important is to find the highest quality tomatoes you can, which are often vine-ripened, so that theyre picked at peak freshness.

    Picking The Best Tomatoes For Caprese Salad

    You cannot make a good caprese salad in the middle of winter. So, if youre reading this in January and hankering for a Caprese, well just wait. Or accept that youre going to be eating something that just doesnt taste like much. Caprese is dominated by the heady, sweet, acidically-accented, umami-tinged flavor of perfectly ripe tomatoes that are fresh as can be andin a perfect worldstill warm from the garden. You want a summer tomatoideally an heirloom variety, because they are just SO much more flavorfulthats just a day or two shy of too ripe. Heres how to track down the best tomatoes for your Caprese:

  • Grow your own! Or make friends with a neighbor with a green thumb and a lot of tomato plants. Alternatively, you can….

  • Head to the farmers market! Produce from your local farmers market is unlikely to have spent much time in cold storage, which means its fresh as can be and quite local, too. For super-ripe heirloom tomatoes, thats essential. The farmers market is also your best bet for really fresh basiltwo birds, one stone!

  • Look for tomatoes without bruising or splitting, but dont be put off by color or shapeheirloom tomatoes come in many colors and shapes.

  • Sniff and hold the tomatoes. A really ripe tomato will be fragrant, especially near where the stem was, and will be heavy for its size .

  • Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This