Creamy Cucumber Salad Recipe With Mayo

Must Try

What Kind Of Cucumbers

Creamy Cucumber Salad With Mayo and Vinegar Recipe

English cucumbers or Persian cucumbers work best in this recipe as they are tastier and have fewer seeds. If you cant find these, you can use garden cucumbers too. You might need to peel their skin though if it tastes bitter. So taste it first and then decide to peel or not. Also, garden cucumbers mostly have bigger seeds, so youd better remove the seeds and then chop for the salad.

How To Make Cucumber Salad With Sour Cream

Wash cucumbers and dry. Use a mandoline to make thin, uniform slices very quickly. Be sure to use the guard and keep your fingers and any skin away from the blade!

Slice the cucumbers right into a large mixing bowl with plenty of room to stir in the dressing. I like to use chilled cucumbers so that salad is ready to eat quickly after being mixed up.

In a small mixing bowl measure out the dressing ingredients. Dill weed can be stirred into the dressing or it can be sprinkled on top.

The dill weed mixes better and gets a more even coating when stirred into the dressing.

Stir all of the dressing ingredients very well.

Pour over sliced cucumbers and stir gently. Chill for at least an hour. Just before serving toss lightly.

Sprinkle with additional dill weed if desired.

More Great Salad Recipes:

Linguine Salad is rich with Italian dressing, salad seasoning, parmesan cheese and chopped vegetables to make a great pasta salad.

Overnight Salad is layered with lettuce, cauliflower, tomatoes, sweet onion, peas, cheddar cheese and bacon bits. This classic salad is topped with a mayonnaise and parmesan cheese dressing.

Broccoli Cauliflower Salad uses cheddar cheese and bacon to add so much flavor to these basic veggies.

Why This Recipe For Creamy Cucumber Dill Salad Works

  • Simplicity is key and this salad uses only cucumber, dill, Greek yogurt and salt/pepper.
  • Quick to make, only 10 minutes for creamy dill salad yogurt from start to finish. There is no peeling or deseeding of the cucumber!
  • Versatile creamy cucumber dill salad with either Greek yogurt or sour cream and you can swap out the fresh dill for fresh herbs that you have on hand, parsley, chives or green onion tastes great!

Read Also: Where Can I Buy A Salad

Creamy Cucumber Salad Is A Summer Tradition

Gardens and farmers markets are currently in their heyday, with all their beautiful summer produce to share. And when the cucumbers are plentiful, you can bet that Im making this classic Creamy Cucumber Salad recipe!

It feels like Ive been eating this fresh cucumber salad all my life. And, come to think of it, its because I have! Mom and Dad had a huge garden on the farm when I was growing up, and this has always been one of my moms favorite salads. This recipe is a summer garden harvest tradition, made with fresh cucumbers, onion, and dill!

This creamy cucumber salad holds all kinds of nostalgia for me. I can picture Mom in the kitchen, slicing up cucumbers and stirring together the dressing without a recipe it always came together by taste.

If you prefer a cucumber salad that isnt creamy, be sure to check out this Cucumber Salad with a tangy vinegar dressing. Our daughter Tessa loves to make this all year round!

So, creamy or not, I have you covered when it comes to cucumber salad!

What to make with cucumbers? Another family favorite recipe is my moms Refrigerator Sweet Pickles my FAVORITE pickle!

If Youre Making Allrecipes Dads Creamy Cucumber Salad A Few Tips

Creamy Cucumber Salad with Tangy Mayo Dressing
  • Use slicing or English cucumbers. The recipe doesnt indicate which type of cucumbers to use . Youll get good results with slicing or English cucumbers.
  • Reduce the mayonnaise to 1 cup. The recipe makes a lot of dressing. Too much, in my opinion. You can easily get away with using 1 cup of mayonnaise some commenters on the original recipe also preferred this approach.
  • Use one large bowl and make the dressing first. Instead of adding the drained cucumbers and onion to a large bowl first, minimize dirty dishes by first stirring together the dressing in the bowl, then adding the vegetables.
  • Use fresh dill. The recipe calls for dried dill, but its worth picking up a bunch of the fresh stuff. Fresh dill is much more flavorful.
  • Make this salad a day in advance. This recipe gets so much better as it sits. The overwhelming taste of the mayonnaise mellows, and all the flavors in the salad meld into something really delicious. If you cant make it a full day in advance, I recommend giving it at least four hours to chill in the fridge.
  • Overall rating: 8/10

    Have you tried Allrecipes Dads Creamy Cucumber Salad recipe? Let us know in the comments!

    Kelli is the Food Editor for Plan & Prep content for Kitchn. She’s a graduate of the French Culinary Institute and author of the cookbooks, Plant-Based Buddha Bowls, The Probiotic Kitchen, Buddha Bowls, and Everyday Freekeh Meals. She lives in New Jersey.

    You May Like: Wishbone Gluten Free Salad Dressings

    Creamy Cucumber Salad Ingredients

    This refreshing summer side dish only needs a few ingredients to make.

    Fresh sliced cucumbers, red onion, mayonnaise, dill and salt and pepper. All you need is 3 ingredients and dill to make this tasty summer salad.

    • Vegetables: cucumbers, pickled red onion or fresh onion
    • Mayonnaise: I prefer Hellman’s or Dukes for the thickest and creamiest flavor in all my recipes.
    • Herb: fresh dill or dried dill weed
    • Seasonings: salt, ground black pepper, a tad of sugar
    • vinegar: if you don’t have time to make red pickled onions you can soak red onion slices in a bit of vinegar for a few minutes before mixing them into the salad to soften them up and add a hint of the vinegar flavor to the salad. Or you can skip this step.

    Directions For Creamy Cucumber Salad Recipe

  • Slice cucumber into thin slices.
  • Slice half a large red onion into small, thin strips.
  • In a large bowl, add Hellmans mayo, sour cream, red wine vinegar, sugar, garlic powder, and Italian seasoning. Stir really well to combine.
  • Add cucumber slices and red onions in the bowl with sauce. Toss to coat and enjoy!
  • And thats it! Only 4 steps and less than 10 ingredients for this delicious salad thats perfect for summer!

    You May Like: 72 Inch Sandwich Salad Prep Refrigerator

    How To Make Cucumber Salad

    This recipe for cucumber salad has 3 folds:

  • Make the Cucumber Dill Salad Dressing, which I will talk more about in a second.
  • Prep your salad ingredients: Slice up cucumbers, radishes, and green onions
  • Assemble it all together.
  • While those steps are stupid easy to follow, often times when yogurt is used in place of sour cream like we do in this Cucumber Dill Salad, you end up with one big issue and that is a soggy salad.

    At first, it is nice and creamy, but as it sits it becomes watery. The good news is that it is an easy fix with just a little bit of advance prep.

    Which Cucumbers Are Best For Salads

    How to Make Creamy Cucumber Salad

    I prefer using the English cucumber, which is mild, sweet, and virtually seedless. Normally, these cucumbers come wrapped in plastic at the grocery. The skin on these cucumbers is thinner and more fragile than the pole cucumber, which is generally what is found in gardens.

    Along with the texture and mild flavor, his cucumber seems to have less water, which makes this a lovely choice for salads.

    Read Also: Chicken Salad Sandwich At Arby’s

    How Long Will Cucumber Salad Keep

    I keep this in the fridge until the cucumbers start to get a little wilty and softI like them crunchy so when they get too soft its a sign for me to toss any leftovers.

    This usually stays crisp for 3-4 days tightly covered in the fridge.

    More summer side dishes you might like:

    Tuna Pasta Salad: This one makes a great lunch or side dish! Its full of pasta, tuna, and avocado.

    Cowboy Beans: You cant have a barbecue without baked beans! These beans are loaded with beef and bacon, too.

    Macaroni Salad Recipe: This is my mamas recipe and it has a unique ingredient that adds a ton of flavor!

    Give this creamy cucumber salad with mayo a try and let me know what you think! And be sure to for more delicious recipes!

    Follow me on social for more recipe ideas & inspiration!

    How To Slice Cucumbers Thin

    If you want an especially great cucumber salad, then slice the cucumbers and onion nice and thin, and both the same thickness. For me, a mandoline is key. I use it regularly its one of my favorite kitchen tools!

    Not only does a mandoline create thin, uniform slices, but it does it QUICKLY!

    If you dont have a mandoline, however, a good sharp chefs knife is all you really need. I promise that your salad will still be a great one. 🙂

    Recommended Reading: Briannas Salad Dressing Creamy Balsamic

    Creamy Cucumber And Tomato Salad

    This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.

    I was given charge over babysitting all 30-something tomato plants this spring while my parents were on a two-week vacation. I didnt realize how important the tomatoes were until I almost killed the lot of them. Ok, it wasnt me, it was a very gusty wind!

    The tomato plants were brought to my house in a portable greenhouse. I noticed that the wind was picking up so I set David down to play with some toys and went outside to pull the greenhouse into the garage.

    You can imagine my horror when I saw that the whole greenhouse had tipped over, all of the plants had come out of their pots and were scattered across the lawn. The entire families organic vegetable crops ruined!! I frantically tried to rescue the tomatoes, but realized I couldnt do it myself, not with David in the house by himself who knows what kind of wails he would be producing. Anyway, I called my sisters to come help.

    We replanted them best we could they looked rather limp. I even prayed over the tomatoes that night . Long story short, all but two of the tomato plants survived. Funny though, the cucumbers and melons looked the same, so when they got planted in the garden, there were some cucumbers springing up with the melons.

    Ingredients For The Best Cucumber Salad

    Creamy Cucumber Salad Recipe With Mayo And Sour Cream

    When it comes to fresh cucumber recipes, this is a super simple one that relies on just a few fresh ingredients plus a handful of pantry staples.

    • Cucumbers Sometimes cucumbers can be bitter, so be sure to taste test them before adding to your salad.
    • Onion Use red, yellow, or white.
    • Dill Fresh dill will always be best!
    • Mayonnaise Part I of the creamy base for the dressing.
    • Sour cream Part II of the creamy base I love a creamy dressing made from mayo and sour cream!
    • White vinegar To loosen up the creamy dressing. This also lends a simple, clean tang to the flavor.
    • Sugar Just a little bit of white sugar.
    • Salt & pepper

    You May Like: How Do You Layer A Taco Salad

    Creamy Cucumber And Onion Salad

    My garden cucumbers are out of control this year! They just became ready about 2 weeks ago and since then, Ive picked over 60 cukes from only a couple of plants. I see plenty of pickles in my future. But other than some gifted cucumbers to family friends, most of the cuke surplus has been made into a couple batches of this, Creamy Cucumber and Onion Salad.

    This recipe, with some modifications, comes from our family friend, Jo.

    Jo is always great for fresh, summer recipes like this Creamy Italian Pasta Salad I posted last year.

    There are 2 keys to this recipe.

    Giving the sliced cucumbers a little salt water soak, before assembling the salad.

    This helps to both season the cukes and have them release some of their excess moisture. Making sure that once you add the dressing it wont become a watered down soup.

    And #2

    You. Have. To. Use. Miracle. Whip!

    Im a mayonnaise girl myself, but this is the one recipe where substituting is not going to be good.

    Dont ask me the science behind it all, but cucumbers and mayonnaise are not friends. The dressing becomes separated and thin.

    Miracle Whip will ensure this recipe stays thick and creamy!

    Take it to a family potluck .

    Or serve alongside your favorite grilled meats and side dishes.

    Its one salad that is sure to be well loved.

    How To Make This Dilled Creamy Cucumber Salad Perfectly

    • Place the red onion slices into a bowl of water. Soak for 20 minutes.
    • Whisk together the salad dressing ingredients. Adjusting the sugar to taste.
    • Place the cucumbers, radishes and drained red onions into a medium-sized bowl. Mix with the salad dressing, adding salt and pepper to taste.
    • Refrigerate until chilled, then serve right away.

    Read Also: Chicken Salad With Grapes And Almonds

    Creamy Cucumber Salad Recipe : View Cooking Videos

    There are two different versions of cucumber salad that you might find, one having a light vinegar sauce, the other being a creamy version creamy cucumber salad recipe. Cool and creamy, this tangy cucumber dip is the perfect complement to grilled meats and vegetables. Cover and refrigerate for at least 1 hour before serving. Apr 30, 2018 · this post may contain affiliate links.

    Red russian salad dressing recipe > from

    Creamy cucumber and tomato pasta salad It’s traditionally made with strained salted sheep’s or goat’s milk yogurt combined with cucumbers, garlic, and herbs. Drizzle with dressing and toss to coat. Mix macaroni, onion, green, red, and yellow bell pepper, celery, and carrots into the dressing until thoroughly coated. Apr 30, 2018 · home » recipes » creamy cucumber and tomato pasta salad. Everything gets tossed in a light creamy dressing and the result is a fresh, slightly tangy pasta salad with plenty of different flavors. There are two different versions of cucumber salad that you might find, one having a light vinegar sauce, the other being a creamy version. Please read my disclosure policy 13 comments.

    Creamy Cucumber Salad Directions:

    Dill Cucumber Salad with Mayonnaise

    Wash, peel, and thinly slice 4 large cucumbers. Score the cucumber with a fork to remove bitterness. Use a mandoline for uniformity. Peel and thinly slice 1 medium sweet onion. Place the sliced cucumbers and onions in a ceramic, glass, or plastic bowl that has a lid.

    In a small bowl combine mayonnaise, sugar, and vinegar. Mix until smooth. Turn the mayonnaise mixture into the cucumber and onion mixture, combine well. Salt and pepper to taste.

    Cover with a lid, shake lightly. Allow the cucumber salad to marinate in the refrigerator for a minimum of 6 hours .

    Refrigerate leftovers.


    If you would like to try more refreshing summer salads, you may like these:

    Cucumber Caprese Salad Hubby came up with this cucumber Caprese salad recipe years ago. It is fresh, easy to make, and totally delicious. It is one of the most popular recipes on my blog.

    Cantaloupe Prosciutto Mozzarella Salad Recipe Just 15 minutes from refrigerator to table for this refreshing and tasty Cantaloupe Prosciutto Mozzarella Salad recipe! Excellent as a dish dish or lunch time meal.

    Four Color Caprese Salad Recipe a riff off Hubbys cucumber caprese salad recipe.

    First Published: July 21, 2014

    For more Recipes on Anns Entitled Life,

    If you enjoyed this post, be sure to sign up for the Anns Entitled Life weekly newsletter, and never miss another article!

    Read Also: Can Dogs Eat Tuna Salad

    How To Make Creamy Cucumber Salad Recipe

  • Make the dressing: Mix all the ingredients for the dressing in a bowl and set aside.
  • Finish the salad: Peel, seed, and slice your cucumbers, chop up your onions, and crumble the feta. Toss everything with the dressing in a large bowl. If youd like, garnish the salad with a bit more chopped dill and some freshly cracked pepper. Serve and enjoy!
  • While I did everything in two steps, you can realistically just toss all the ingredients into a bowl and mix. The reason I like to mix the dressing separately is so that I can make sure the sugar, salt, and pepper are all evenly dispersed.

    Creamy Dill Cucumber Salad Faqs

    Can I make creamy cucumber and onion salad ahead of time?

    Yes, you can, and I encourage it. The longer the flavors have to marry, the better! I like to refrigerate it, but only for a couple of hours. If you plan to make this a day in advance, note that cucumbers will start to get soggy and watery if refrigerated for too long.

    In this case, its best to store cucumbers and onions in one airtight container and the creamy dill sauce in another. A little before youre ready to serve, mix together.

    If you have some extra time before serving, I would suggest adding the cucumbers to a bowl, adding some salt, and letting them sit in the refrigerator for awhile. This will ensure the cucumbers dont release too much liquid within the salad. Your salad will be a lot creamier this way, but its not essential. If you want to get the salad on the table in 30 minutes, you can skip this step!

    Can I add anything else to this recipe?

    Of course! Adding in veggies like purple cabbage provides a beautiful pop of color, plus its delicious. If you want to spice it up a notch, try adding a couple of jalapeno slices for that kick of heat. Keep in mind that adding other vegetables will affect the total carb count.

    How long can creamy dill cucumber salad sit out for serving?

    You shouldnt leave cucumber salad out for more than 2 hours. If possible, keep your cucumber dill salad on ice to keep it fresh longer.

    I dont like the flavor of dill. Do I have to use it?

    How do I store cucumber salad?

    Recommended Reading: How Much Is A Chick Fil A Cobb Salad

    Popular Articles

    More Recipes Like This